Guitar Island, Long Island: A Things-To-Do Guide for a Perfect Day Outdoors

Colloquially known among local boaters for its distinctive outline, “Guitar Island” refers to a small, guitar-shaped sandbar/islet off Long Island. It’s a low-key, natural spot—no boardwalks, concessions, or lifeguards—just sun, sea, birds, and shallow water ideal for dropping anchor and unwinding. If you’re looking for a quiet, nature-forward escape on Long Island’s waters, this guide will help you plan a safe, responsible, and memorable visit.

At a Glance

• Vibe: Laid-back, nature-oriented, bring-your-own-everything.
• Access: By private boat, kayak/SUP on calm days, or private charter; no public ferry.
• Amenities: None. Pack in/pack out.
• Best For: Anchoring and relaxing, beachcombing, birdwatching, paddling, photography.
• Season: Late spring through early fall for water fun; shoulder seasons for bird migration.
• Stay Length: 2–6 hours for a day stop; longer if you’re cruising.

Top Things to Do

1) Anchor and Sandbar Hangouts

Slip into shallow, protected water and enjoy a classic Long Island sandbar day. Bring a float, beach chairs that work in ankle-deep water, and a shade canopy.

Pro tip

Choose a slack-tide window for the easiest approach and departure, and give neighboring boats a respectful buffer.

2) Paddle the Flats (Kayak/SUP)

Glassy shallows around the islet are perfect for short paddles when wind is light. Explore gently to spot schools of baitfish and wading birds, and avoid disturbing eelgrass beds if present.

Pro tip

Use a short fin on your SUP for skinny water and carry a leash and PFD.

3) Beachcombing and Shelling

Comb the wrack line for shells and driftwood. Leave natural items where you found them if they’re part of a sensitive habitat, and follow any posted regulations.

4) Birdwatching and Coastal Wildlife

Expect terns, oystercatchers, sandpipers, and occasional osprey overhead. In colder months, seals may haul out on remote sandbars in the region—observe quietly from a distance.

• Wildlife etiquette: Keep at least 150 feet (45 m) from seals and nesting birds; give extra space if you notice any agitation.

5) Photography (Aerial and Shoreline)

From the right vantage, the island’s silhouette is a standout. Golden hour adds texture to ripples and sand patterns.

Drone note

Recreational drone use must follow FAA rules; never fly over people or wildlife, and check for local/park restrictions or temporary flight restrictions before launching.

6) Fishing and Shellfishing

Nearby channels and edges can hold fluke, schoolie stripers, and cocktail blues in season. Shellfishing (like clamming) may be possible in designated areas with local permits and open waters.

• Regulations: Check current New York State and town rules, size limits, seasons, and closures.

7) Sunset, Stargazing, and Quiet Evenings

If you’re on a cruising boat, lingering at anchor after the day boats leave offers superb sunset color and star-filled skies on clear nights.

Planning and Access

How to Get There

• By boat: Private vessel is the most common. Approach at mid-to-high tide for extra margin over shoals.
• By paddle: Suitable for experienced paddlers only on calm, low-wind days with slack tide and short crossings.
• Charters: Some local captains run custom sandbar days; inquire at marinas in South Shore and East End towns.

Important: Depending on the exact sandbar and shifting shoals, the area may be subject to town, state, or conservation rules. Confirm access and any landings restrictions with local authorities and observe posted signs on-site.

Anchoring Etiquette and Seagrass Care

• Favor sandy patches for anchoring; avoid scarring eelgrass beds where marked or visible.
• Use sufficient scope for tides and set a snubber to minimize swing and noise.
• Keep music low; sound carries far over water.

Best Time to Visit

• Late spring–early fall: Warm water, sandbar-friendly weather, and longer days.
• Shoulder seasons: Migratory bird activity increases; cooler, fewer crowds.
• Weekdays/mornings: Calmer and less crowded than peak weekend afternoons.

Safety Essentials

• Tides and currents: Some sections may flood at high tide; check local tide tables and plan arrivals/departures at favorable windows.
• Weather: Keep an eye on wind shifts and thunderstorms; conditions change quickly on open bays.
• No lifeguards, no services: Bring your own water, shade, and first-aid kit.
• Foot protection: Wear water shoes for shell fragments and hot sand.
• Sun and bugs: Broad-spectrum sunscreen, hats, and insect repellent (greenhead flies can be persistent on certain days).

Responsible Visiting

• Leave No Trace: Pack out all trash, including food scraps and fishing line.
• Respect closures: Seasonal nesting areas for shorebirds may be roped off; do not enter.
• Fires and grills: Often prohibited on small sandbars; verify local regulations.
• Pets: Keep leashed where allowed; avoid wildlife and hot mid-day sand.

What to Pack

• Lightweight anchor and line, shore stakes if needed
• Sun shade or beach umbrella with sand anchors
• Plenty of water and electrolyte drinks; snacks or a picnic
• Dry bag for phone, keys, and camera
• Reef-safe sunscreen, hat, UV shirt, sunglasses with retainer
• Water shoes, towel, and a small brush for sand
• Binoculars for birdwatching
• Basic first-aid kit and marine safety gear (PFDs for all)
• Trash bags and reusable containers

Family- and Pet-Friendly Tips

• Kids: Lifejackets on at all times near the water; set clear boundaries around boats and anchors.
• Shade and hydration: Build a “cool-down” area; schedule active play for mornings or late afternoons.
• Pets: Bring fresh water, a collapsible bowl, paw protection if sand is hot, and waste bags.

Sample Half-Day Itinerary

• 08:30 Depart at mid-tide, calm wind forecast.
• 09:15 Set anchor in a sandy patch; confirm hold and swing room.
• 09:30 Beachcombing and birdwatching along the waterline.
• 10:30 SUP/kayak loop around the shallows; hydrate and snack.
• 12:00 Picnic under shade; quiet time, reading, or photos.
• 13:30 Weigh anchor before wind increases and tide turns.

Nearby Pairings on Long Island

• Barrier beach day: Combine with a visit to oceanfront parks like Robert Moses or Jones Beach for surf and boardwalk amenities.
• Fire Island villages: Stroll car-free communities, boardwalks, and lighthouse trails.
• North Fork/Harbor towns: Explore Greenport, local wineries, and waterside dining after your sandbar session.
• Montauk/End-to-end cruise: For boaters on a longer itinerary, add coves, inlets, and lighthouse photography.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a public ferry to Guitar Island?

No. Access is typically by private boat, paddlecraft on suitable days, or private charter. There are no facilities on-site.

Can I land on the sandbar?

It depends. Some sandbars are open to passive use, while others can be privately owned or seasonally restricted for wildlife. Obey posted signs and check with local town or state authorities before landing.

Are drones allowed?

Drone use must comply with FAA rules and any local restrictions. Never disturb wildlife or other visitors; avoid flying over people and nesting areas.

What about restrooms and trash?

There are none. Pack out everything you bring, and plan restroom breaks before or after your visit at marinas or on your vessel if equipped.

Final Thoughts

Guitar Island’s appeal lies in its simplicity—a natural sandbar escape shaped by wind and tide. With a bit of planning, respect for regulations and wildlife, and a light footprint, your visit can be a highlight of a Long Island summer or a peaceful shoulder-season retreat.